So Just How Many Cookies did Jimmy Have?

If Jimmy has negative seven cookies and eats the square root of them, does he have more than zero left?

This question was, of course, primarily designed to make fun of the limited number of applications that exist for some of the most interesting pieces of mathematics.  Even the few applications that do exist for imaginary numbers are rather esoteric and obscure.  But it is no surprise that departure from real numbers makes applicability in the real world sparse.

However, for those of you quixotics who, like me, don’t care so much about the real world, I have decided to write a brief discussion of the topic.  The question is: Is i root seven positive or negative?  Most people will want to say it is positive, but consider the following:

i=-iThe fact that = –might leave some readers confused.  There are many ways of looking at this, but here’s the one that I prefer:  is neither negative nor positive, it is imaginary, and only real numbers can be compared with zero.  When we say “negative i,” what we really mean is “times negative one”.  can have a real coefficient, but, being imaginary, has no sign.  Therefore, the number of cookies Jimmy had is a truly matter of philosophical inquiry.

A friend of mine put it well: “He has something other than zero cookies, but really, he has nothing–except in his imagination”.

Therefore, the answer to the question posed earlier (Is i root seven positive or negative?) is no.


Add something to the discussion.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s